Ethnic Groups Change the Narrative

Ethnic Groups Change the Narrative

El Cid! Hero of Spain, against the Islamic Moors.

The central drama of Spanish and Portuguese history is the Reconquista. The liberation of Spain and Portugal from Muslim tyranny. In the case of Spain, it took 781 years (from 711 to 1492AD).

One would think that such a long struggle would inoculate Latin culture against any sympathies for an Arab cause. And, in the general population, with Spanish and Portuguese ancestry, that might be the case.

However, Arabs have risen to places of prominence in Latin America. And while Jews are nowhere near as prominent as they are in the United States, they still have clout (especially in Argentina).

Much like the United States, Latin America was a land of immigrants. However, unlike the United States, Latin America tended to get more Spanish, Italian, French, and Arab immigrants by percentages than the United States. Latin America veered towards South European and Mediterranean stocks. Hence, it remained heavily Catholic.

The one exception were large amounts of Germans, who – contrary to popular misperceptions – the majority of whom were NOT nazis. Outlier groups like occasional Irish and/or British went to Latin America.

Only recently, historically, have Protestants/Evangelicals made themselves felt in Latin America, chiefly in Brazil and Chile.

But Latin America was culturally homogenous for much of that time.

However, very prosperous Arabs and Jewish groups(though small) are swaying the discussion.

All of this is coming into play during this Gaza War.

Palestinian-Chileans Are Not Taking the 2023 Gaza Operation Well

Palestinian-Chileans Are Not Taking the 2023 Gaza Operation Well

Source: Why Chile’s Response to the Israel-Hamas War Stands Out – Foreign Policy October 13, 2023

Chile, for its part, is home to the largest Palestinian diaspora outside of the Middle East. Migration peaked in the early 20th century, and the Palestinian Chilean population is estimated at between 300,000 and 500,000 people. The size of the community has impacted Chilean culture, domestic politics, and foreign policy for years. A first-division soccer club is named Palestino FC, and its logo features the colors of the Palestinian flag. The Chilean legislature boasts a large Palestinian caucus. In 2005, Chile became one of the first non-Arab countries to join the Arab League as an observer.

A smaller Jewish community of some 20,000 people also live in the country …

Powerful Chilean congressional and private sector groups have campaigned for Palestinian human rights for years, and the public conversation about the escalating situation in Israel-Palestine over the past week has often taken a more long-term, historical perspective than elsewhere in the Americas, including in the United States.

Chilean analysts who have appeared on television and radio programs and written in newspapers following this weekend’s attack have spoken not only about Hamas’s rampage through southern Israel but also about its broader context. …

That’s not to say that Chile’s public debate was without major rifts and controversies. The Palestinian Chilean mayor of a municipality within the Santiago metropolitan area, Daniel Jadue, tweeted immediately after the attack that “the people of Palestine have a right to resist” before later condemning violence against civilians. When asked about Jadue’s comments, the Israeli ambassador said “they crossed all the lines” while acknowledging that many other Chilean Palestinians had directly condemned the Hamas attacks.

Chile is an outlier. Because of its Palestinian population, which is rich and influential, Chile cannot be expected to tow the Western Line when it comes to Israel or Zionism.

Even though most of Chile’s Palestinians are Christian, many descended from refugees who fled Muslim persecution in the 19th and early 20th centuries, they have a blind spot about “Palestine.” They hate the Jewish state, and are vehemently opposed to Israel.

The Palestinian Community is organizing to get its own side of the story about the Hamas-Israel war out to the public.

They had a public meeting on October 11.

As this video of CLUB PALESTINO (social club( shows, the Palestinians (nicknamed: The Chilestinos) are a political force to be reckoned with.


Posted on YouTube: 2023

So the Chilean government did support Israel … officially, but do so gingerly.

Source: DiarioUChile (University of Chile Daily) – October 7, 2023

Gobierno de Chile condena ataque de Hamás y expresa solidaridad con el pueblo Israel


Government of Chile condemns Hamas attack and expresses solidarity with the Israeli people (translated by Google)

Palestinian-Chileans Fight to Preserve Their Culture

Palestinian-Chileans Fight to Preserve Their Culture


Posted on YouTube around June 2023

Chile has the largest Palestinian community outside of the Mideast. And now, France 24 Español has done a video report on the community.

You can get English subtitles by following the instructions below:

This is in Spanish, but it there is an option to have it translated to English.

But the Palestinians in Chile are a prosperous and major political force in South America. They can be called Chilestinos, and they are over 90% Christian.

Many of their ancestors fled the Holy Land around the end of the 19th century and the beginning of the 20th. The Ottoman Empire ruled the Holy Land at that time, and the Christians were fleeing the abuse they suffered at the hands of the Muslim Turks.

Many of them went to Chile.

Given that the Palestinian cause today is often conflated with Islam (such as with Hamas or Islamic Jihad) — and given that their ancestors were persecuted by Muslims — it is odd that the Chilestinos are so caught up in the Palestinian cause.

But they are.

There identification with the land overrides any religious animosities that might have existed.

Chile’s President Wants to Open an Embassy in Palestine

Chile’s President Wants to Open an Embassy in Palestine

This will cause some issues:

Soruce: Times of Israel – Dec 22, 2022

SANTIAGO, Chile — President Gabriel Boric of Chile, whose country has the largest Palestinian population outside of the Middle East, said Wednesday that he planned to open an embassy “in Palestine.”

The announcement by the leftist president, who began his four-year term in March 2022, came at a Christmas ceremony for Chile’s Palestinian community, estimated to be more than 300,000 strong.

“One of the decisions we have taken as a government, I think we have not yet made it public… is that we will raise the level of our official representation in Palestine,” Boric said. “We will open an embassy under our government.”

Chile has a large, prosperous, and powerful Palestinian community, so this wsa probably inevitable, but it will be controversial.

Page 6 of 28
1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 28